Enough about Iran, lets talk Pakistan

There is a country which has well-publicised links to extremist Islamic terrorists, has a long-standing beef with one of its neighbours,  is dangerously unstable, and has around 100 nukes ready to go… and surprise, surprise, it is not Iran.

Leaving aside the question of whether Iran is pursuing nuclear weapons and what that might mean, Pakistan is still the number one risk for something unpleasant going down. North Korea might enjoy rattling its sabre and low-key showing off its giant-breeding programme but Pyongyang knows its nukes are effectively a bargaining tool and a defensive weapon, and are highly unlikely to ever use them. There is always a risk of a collapsing North Korean regime firing off its nukes in a final blaze of un-glory or selling nuclear secrets/weapons to other regimes/terrorists, and although these are scary scenarios they are not as pressing as the issue of Pakistan.

Pakistan is after all a country where a handful of militants can storm a military base and hold it for 16 hours, and where a terror suspect with a $10,000,000 bounty on his head can live in the open, taunting a government that is in theory an ally of his own. And don’t forget that the Taliban already have control over a sizeable chunk of Pakistan. Meanwhile, despite their leaders attending cricket games together, India and Pakistan are still an incident away from full-blown war. Overall then the risk of something scary and nuclear happening in Pakistan is probably higher than any other country by a considerable distance. Islamic extremists steal a nuke? Nuclear war with India? State collapse and lost nukes in the chaos? With so many potential scenarios it must be about time for a Tom Clancy novel on the subject. Maybe this is why Pakistan is stoking the fire in the Iran nuke debate – to divert the world’s eyes from their own impending sh*tstorm. Still, it is nice to see a nuclear power not being a hypocritical dickwad to Iran like all the others.

So why doesn’t Pakistan’s situation get more attention? I don’t recall it being mentioned at all during the recent nuclear  security summit in South Korea, which included Pakistan as a participant. My take on it is that Pakistan is almost too much of a threat to stability and security in South Asia to be told to buck up its act. It is, despite appearances to the contrary sometimes, a vital “ally” in the war in Afghanistan and is a big power thanks largely to those very nukes. Furthermore there is the very hard question of what can be done about it. Clearly stabilising the Pakistani state would help a lot but given the current political situation in Pakistan this seems unlikely. If India gave up its nukes there is perhaps a chance Pakistan would too, but I wouldn’t bet on it – regardless of whether India has nukes, Pakistan having them is a good deterrent against India. Plus India wouldn’t want to give up their nukes unless China gave up theirs, and China wouldn’t unless the US and Russia gave up theirs, and they wouldn’t until Britain, France, and North Korea gave up theirs and if all that happened then it might actually be useful to have some nukes because they could thaw hell out of its deep-freeze. At least Israel would still have some…

So yeah, its kind of one of those problems without an easy answer. Makes you just want to ignore it and go chasing Joseph Kony through the African jungle or something. Of course if it is ignored it might just stay as it is with a risk there but nothing actually happening. However, with US and Chinese aid and support Pakistan might be able to stabilise and stamp out the extremists, and come to some sort of long-term understanding with India to reduce the risk of conflict between them. This may be what will happen anyway, but until that day the safety and security of Pakistani nukes and the need to maintain peaceful Pakistani-Indian relations should be just as high on the international diplomatic agenda as North Korea or Iran, if not higher. Plus as a bonus for cricket fans like myself, if their country became more stable and peaceful Pakistan’s team would be able to play home games again without the hotel they and their opponents are staying at being bombed. That sucked.


3 responses to “Enough about Iran, lets talk Pakistan

  • E. Puha

    The US doesn’t seem to have any coherent policy with regards to Pakistan. I wouldn’t be surprised if they were supporting several opposing factions simultaneously. US drone attacks and pressure on the Pakistani govt. to launch attacks on militants in the tribal zones has been a major source of destabilization. A sensible and coherent US policy towards Pakistan, which recognises how precarious the situation is, would go a long way towards calming the situation. This would of course be at the risk of massive, world wide casualties as people collapse in shock at the prospect of a sensible and coherent US policy towards anything.

    • fromthefourthcorner

      Agreed. The real test of Pakistani stability will come when the US pull out of Afghanistan. If a resurgent Taliban regain ground in Afghanistan what will that do to their activities in the FATA?

      I think its hard for the US to have a coherent policy towards Pakistan precisely because of situation there. The US currently needs Pakistan more than the other way around, and that dictates intercations between them. Look at the way both sides acted with the Bin Laden raid – they didn’t exactly seem like allies for a while there!

  • GUEST POST : Pakistan, Afghanistan, and the elephant in the room! « Daily World Watch

    […] to many observers both within and outside it. This is worrying because, as I wrote in my first ever blog post, Pakistan’s nuclear capability makes any possibility of state failure there particularly […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: